| Children |
| | 1. Asa Metcalf, b. 16 Jan 1739/40, Greenwich, Washington, New York, USA [Father: natural] [Mother: natural] |
| | 2. Elijah Metcalf, b. 19 Oct 1747, Rutland, Worcester, Massachusetts, USA [Father: natural] [Mother: natural] |
| | 3. Deborah Metcalf, b. 13 Feb 1742/43, Rutland, Worcester, Massachusetts, USA [Father: natural] [Mother: natural] |
| | 4. Tabitha Metcalf, b. 1752, Barre, Worcester, Massachusetts, USA [Father: natural] [Mother: natural] |
| | 5. Joseph Metcalf, b. 22 Aug 1754, Barre, Worcester, Massachusetts, USA [Father: natural] [Mother: natural] |
| | 6. Silence Metcalf, b. 24 Aug 1758, Barre, Worcester, Massachusetts, USA [Father: natural] [Mother: natural] |
| | 7. Nathan Metcalf, b. 8 Jul 1745, Rutland, Worcester, Massachusetts, USA d. Salisbury, Herkimer, New York, USA [Father: natural] [Mother: natural] |
|